String immutability: method returns new string
Quick summary
You called s.upper() or s.replace() without assigning the result — strings are immutable, so the original is unchanged.
Why this happens
You called a string method without assigning the return value, expecting the original string to be modified in-place
You chained methods but forgot that each returns a new string and the intermediate results are discarded
You assumed strings are mutable like lists, but string methods always return a new string object
Minimal example
s = 'hello'
s.upper() # result discarded!
print(s) # 'hello' — unchangeds = 'hello'
s = s.upper() # assign the result
print(s) # 'HELLO'Strings are immutable in Python, so upper() returns a new string — assigning it back to s replaces the reference with the uppercase version.
How to diagnose
Print the string before and after the method call to confirm it did not change
Check if the method call result is captured in a variable or discarded as a bare expression
Use id() to verify that the string object identity changes after the method call
How to fix
Assign the result of the string method back to the variable: s = s.upper() or s = s.replace('a', 'b')
Chain methods with assignment: s = s.strip().lower().replace('old', 'new')
Use a list of characters if you need in-place mutation, then join() back to a string when done
How to prevent
Remember that Python strings are immutable — always assign method results to a variable
Use a linter that warns about discarded expression results (bare string method calls)
Related Resources
Related Glossary
Related Lessons
- Strings
Learn about string methods.